Looking at some of the responses here, I'm a bit baffled, and I'll go into some detail why. First, we see civilians on many starfleet ships, not just Galaxies. The Defiant was built specifically for superior combat operations. Was the Enterprise-D the first Galaxy class starship? The Defiant is in a completely different category than a Galaxy class. This video is highly rated by Class 6 students and has been viewed 3 times. It can separate into two parts, but doing so leaves the saucer section a large, FTL-less target without its main reactor to power its shields or weapons and the stardrive section without its main battery or main computer. On-screen, we've seen this over and over again in both the shows and the movies. The Galaxy and similar classes on the other hand are huge cruisers - turn like a barn, outfitted with (weaker) beam-based weaponry, and can take quite a pounding. The Sovereign Project attempted to push the envelope as far as possible when it came to computer power, shielding, armament and systems capabilities. In 2367, Starfleet was exposed to the full force of the Borg in the Battle of Wolf 359. Also we got the Dominionwar Galaxy's which were empty for huge parts of the ship, indicating that there was a hard limit to which they could strip new weapons and stuff to the ship either energy source or some other limit. These variants are the two Galaxy-Uprated versions and Galaxy-Incomplete – each making changes to the spaceframe because of unforeseen threats. The designer is reported as saying the Sovereign is built to fight the Borg - that gives us only about seven years from conception to service, compared to twenty years for the Galaxy class. When Admiral James Leyton seized … That doesn't seem like a very compelling argument. Crew complement is about 1k, fleet command staff is several dozen extra, whatever else is there - intel, counterintel, security etc and it comes to a lot of ppl. The Defiant however, was specifically built as a tool to destroy Cubes. Even though the Galaxy Class is a relatively young class of Starship, Starfleet and the Advanced Starship Design Bureau were forced to devise three variants on the Galaxy space frame. Re: Sovereign class vs Galaxy class vs D'Deridex class Post by Mike DiCenso » Mon May 14, 2012 8:35 am I split the Data verus Optimus Prime fight posts and moved them to the Other analysis, crossovers, and debates forum. Propose future topics for SFF topic challenges! you could be right, in one of the movies Picard even states something along the lines of "remember when we used to be explorers" indicating that their current or recent missions indeed were something different. The Galaxy class starship is described as "the largest and most powerful starship of its time" whereas the Defiant-class is characterised as a "limited role weapons platform". All that volume seems to allow for a great deal of versatility. (TNG: \"The Pegasus\")The warp core was designed at Outpost Seran T-1 on stardate 4… ratios: why is the ratio of this equation like so? Well but apart from that i agree with your statement. The Galaxy Class Starship Development Project began in the 2350s at Utopia Planitia Fleet Yards. Unless you envision missions that would really take advantage of the Galaxy-class ship’s vast usable space and crew support capabilities, I believe the Sovereign is more practical for most purposes. More diplomatic facilities, crew facilities, research facilities, colonization support, combat, etc. also, NCC-1701E is a Sovereign-class, not Galaxy. The Sovereign-class was introduced during the early 2370s, and was, at the time, the most advanced starship design in the fleet. Good arguments that you have there. Answers like this help me the most to form my own idea of the subject and some of your Arguments i will use and tell to my players so they have to decide on the basis of some good arguments for and against each starship. The Galaxy-class began development in the year 2343 and has the dubious distinction of having the longest design, development and construction period of any class in Starfleet history—delayed for a further year due to attempted sabotage by the Manraloth Giriaenn that was only just exposed by Lieutenant Data—with the prototype USS Galaxy finally launching in 2357 and its first two sister ships the ev… newcommand for Zhuyin/Bopomofo tone marks next to Chinese character. And finally a thing where i see the Sovereign indeed as superior is with its max warp speed as well as drive efficiency. Saved by Keith Rowley-Yugenro. They're heavily armed and expected to go into battle at a moment's notice should a conflict situation arise. Nowhere it says how powerful pulse cannons are, but at least each pulse to be equivalent to power of 2 phaser emitters (as in. Let that really sink in. I … However, taking into account crew inefficiency as described earlier it would count as a sort-of-answer. while the Sovereign, being smaller, is faster both at warp and impulse, and has a much better range of auxiliary craft. my thoughts: I tried to come up with an answer myself and also wanted to let an young servent of the Admiral list some Advantages and disadvantages to both ships. The Lea Brahms hologram notes that certain developments in the production of the Enterprise-D would be included in the next class of starship. And it dismantles a lot of my ideas on why and how the Galaxy could be superior to the Sovereign. Sovereign-class For additional meanings of "Sovereign class", please see Sovereign class (disambiguation). The initial design receiv… I might explain the differences to the players in those terms (or whatever tradeoffs you decide on) and let them pick between the two. Well i run a pen and paper StarTrek game in which one of my players "the commander" took command over their own ship after the (non player) Captain died. Only the Drive and Warpspeed i doubt since i believe the thinner Warp Bubble of the Sovereign is here in the advantage. Maybe you need a universal translator? Because i believe the Architecture of the Sovereign is actually improved so it will always with similar tech have an advantage in both speed as well as evasive maneuvers (because smaller target compared to the galaxy class). Defiant class is not long range/extended cruise capable... As I said in my answer, because of the inconsistent writing people often over-estimate the relative power of the Defiant-class. And you are corrrect that the Ratio of firepower on the Defiant is better equipped. The Sovereign-class starship was one of the most advanced Federation Starfleet designs of the late 24th century. Many technical websites say the Sovereign class has a Type 8 warp core. Yes, while the Galaxy-class could be refit, so could the Sovereign. You've made lots of bold statements but provided zero evidence to support any of them. How was that superiority measured if not evaluation against current inventory. The Galaxy was intended to be refitted and even in the deckplans by Rick Sternbach there are spaces left out and marked with "for future upgrades". Since the Sovereign has an overall 84.6% increase in phaser capability over the Galaxy Class. There is absolutely no reason to think that similar upgrades couldn't be made to a Galaxy. They had some help from Rom which caused a power failure, but the Defiant was still putting up a strong fight. You could, but I'm not sure how much that would help you. The Sovereign-class is a type of starship built by Starfleet from the late 24th century into the 25th century. I see. also, NCC-1701E is a Sovereign-class, not Galaxy. Is the USS Defiant (Defiant class) or the NCC 1701-E Enterprise (Sovereign class) a stronger ship for battle? That evidence suggests the ship was considered fairly successful across timelines and universes and is pretty versatile. exactly like that i would probably act. Both are multi mission ships and both are in principle capable to carry out all kind of missions but i think what the refitted Galaxy lacks for example in firepower and agility the sovereign lacks in laboratory and sensor space as well as manpower to run that many labs. We thought it would be for battle to present a smaller profile which does make sense but i argue that it also benefits the drive systems. But with time and a little effort i agree it should be possible which is why i asked for both ships being refitted to the same tech standard since i wanted only to know which ships frame do you think is better over all if it could be updated to be technologically equally. That is why the Enterprise F and the size of the Odyssey-Class made a lot of sense to me. Given the above, I can't think of many scenarios where I would *prefer* a Sovereign over a Galaxy. @Valorum - Clouds? The Sovereign-class starship was introduced in the late 24th century, showcasing some of Starfleet's most recent technological advances. The sovereign, on the other hand, was designed and built during a time of conflict, and would have improvements aimed at addressing the shortcomings of previous technologies, and the more advanced tech would be able to compensate for the reduced manpower, as fewer civilian facilities means more labs and equipment instead. 3 - The mirror Defiant was able to take out the mirror equivalent to the Neg'var, the Klingon's most powerful ship. But think of other points too like personal responsibilities, how comfortable would you live on the ship, would it be more a burden or a blessing to be allowed to take civilians (like your wife and children) with you, what missions would the ship usually be used for, how long would the Missions probably be (Galaxy with its civilian and also bigger crew could probably stay out for far longer while being still psychologically healthy), do you really want to be stationed on the tactically more capable ship which is maybe more likely to be send into battle or dangerous areas or on the other hand go with a ship which is less likely to go to battle but also missing the small edge that would maybe ensure your survival, which is more comfortable to live on, which promises to be able to be refitted more and longer to the state of the art? The hammer might be a perfectly good and useful hammer, but it's not a saw. Introduced in the 2370s, the Sovereign class was first battle-tested in the Battle of Sector 001 in 2373. Is there a task force? also, NCC-1701E is a. Defiant en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/Paradise_Lost_(episode), February 2021 Topic Challenge: Hal Clement, Opt-in alpha test for a new Stacks editor, Visual design changes to the review queues. torpedo) launchers, at least 2 aft torpedo launchers, Defenses: Deflector shields, ablative armor, Speed: Warp 9.9 (Automatic engine shutdown after 10 minutes), Armament: 12/14 phaser arrays; 2 torpedo launchers; 250 photon torpedoes; antimatter mines. Most of the arguments that I've seen in favor of the Sovereign boil down to this; it's got more weapons and it's faster. Its possible the Mirandas had hulls that could withstand newer warp engines while the warp engine didn't advance much between the Excelsior type ship up to the Nebula and Galaxy classes with the Ambassador being dead ends, not worth refitting. The main hull has two up-swept pylons attached to it which lead to the ship's nacelles. The Enterprise is a science ship (with an impressive amount of weapons, yes) and not designed with combat in mind. I think it depends on what sort of missions you want them to engage in. The Sovereign class has an elongated saucer section connected to the main hull with a streamlined and interconnected neck area. The Sovereign features an array of different Turrets and balanced stats for taking on a variety of ships. Same. do you think the Sovereign-Class is always and in all areas superior. With phasers almost hitting at light speeds and Torpedoes which follow targets and have a much quicker turn rate than any ship that carries humans it stands up to debate anyway if the smaller target of a sovereign or even a shuttle is really that much harder to hit. The Galaxy Class Starship Development Project began in the 2350s at Utopia Planitia Fleet Yards. Moreover, for one moment we can see how the saucer of the Excelsior class overlaps with the Enterprise-D engines behind it, exhibiting a dark seam. A capital ship is by definition a multi-purpose ship. I am gonna be looking into SFC:3, it sounds fun. I just don't know where that in-universe info is so I post to the good people here for help. That is why it's smaller than Galaxy, but with more punch. in the next two movies, the ship is shown with pretty major external changes. Your estimate starts to break down if you consider the size and manoeuvrability of the vessels. She is better suited that the Sovereign-Class for such longterm exploration and scientific missions. … The power generator must be a major innovation. Only things i can hold against are that we don't know if the Galaxy is an Excelsior which were able to be refitted quiet long or an Ambassador-class which we get to see almost not at all which indicates that those ships weren't as good to refit and keep around longer. My answer: The Galaxy Class, and it's not even close. By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. Although smaller than Galaxy-class starships, this class of vessel is still a very versatile exploration vessel and is considered to be one of the most advanced class of ships in the Federation. Re: Sovereign class vs Galaxy class vs D'Deridex class Post by Mike DiCenso » Wed Dec 14, 2011 9:14 pm That I think depends on if we are talking an early model Galaxy-class starship, or one of the kick-ass Dominion War Galaxy class. (Star Trek: First Contact, Star Trek: Insurrection, Star Trek Nemesis) Control of the Sovereign class was one of the decisive factors in the Federation Civil War of 2372-2374. On the other hand a Sovereign has more then three times the forward firepower of a Galaxy as well as superior shields and armor. Although it's a fairly speculative answer (since in-universe there's never been a direct conflict between the two ships) we can make some reasonable suppositions based on the relative performance versus ships from enemy races and the one instance in which the Defiant faced a reasonably armed Federation ship. Major removals only happen if there was a serious design issue (stability of the Atlanta-class cruisers in WW2 comes to mind as they were too top-heavy because of all the turrets). The Sovereign-class Odyssey was near completion in November, 2378, but no permanent registry number had as yet been assigned. Latest Blog Post: Favorite Questions and Answers from Fourth Quarter 2020. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. In a 'stand-up' fight, the Galaxy-class would be the clear and immediate winner. What kind of relationship are you supposed to have if you only return every 3-5 or even 10 years home? So i would guess the possibility to take your family with you is great for the psychologic health. Galaxy can host up to 5k ppl (IIRC)? I would suppose how you would measure it. In the DS9 episode Shattered Mirror, a defiant-class ship engages a Klingon Neg'var class craft and forces it into retreat. I tried better this time. Even if there was theoretically room for more science labs, what use is that? rev 2021.2.5.38499, The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, Learn more about hiring developers or posting ads with us. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. The Sovereign-class began development in 2365 and was intended to be the latest and greatest in Starfleet exploration starships. Even today a naval ship produced ten years later would not be very different in technology. Like the Galaxy-class before it, the Sovereign-class was designed with the ability to reversibly separate the primary and secondary hulls in a process called saucer separation, often truncated sau-sep. Even on TNG, Enterprise wasn't usually conducting experiments or exploring, but assisting the team that was doing so. Why would the side of the moon that faces earth be as dark as the far side of the moon? – AcePL Mar 8 '19 at 15:54. add a comment | Sovereign = Faster so it can be there sooner and also has a large Sickbay complex so she can too help many but lesser at the same time as the Galaxy. Even though the Galaxy Class is a relatively young class of Starship, Starfleet and the Advanced Starship Design Bureau were forced to devise three variants on the Galaxy space frame. At the time everyone thought it just meant the Admirals were keeping Picard out of the way of the Borg. Even if there was theoretically room for more science labs, what use is that? The Galaxy class is more like the refitted Midway class: stronger than most, and with better ECM, but not extremely well armored except for critical areas. After suffering such huge loses with almost no damage done to the Borg cube, Starfleet's entire policy of starship design shifte… USS Agamemnon - NPC USS Liverpool - NPC USS Colossus - NPC USS Canopus - NPC Starship Design Statistics. Which vessels in the Star Trek universe have beaten a Galaxy Class starship in one-on-one combat? David vs Goliath, or even just a really good/clever captain or pilot could conceivably turn the tables in a fight even if they are technically outclassed. On the other hand with phaserbeams which hit almost at lightspeed and torpedos which can follow a target and have a much sharper turn rate since no people are on board which could be killed if the inertia dampeners fail because the ship turns to fast, well it stands up to discussion whether the size difference would actually play that much of a role. It only takes a minute to sign up. The point of putting a science lab on a starship is that the science needs to be done at a specific location. But the problem is apart from the max Warp Speed and Combat potential i hardly see real advantages the Sovereign-Class could have over the Galaxy-Class especially if she is refitted to newest standards. It was so named in honor of the Galaxy-class Odyssey, which was lost to the Dominion in 2370. How do these lines in Shakespeare's Sonnet 151 mean what they're supposed to? This isn't a result of design, but policy. I've only ever seen the "Explorer" terminology used in games and beta canon. Both the Defiant and Nova projects were … Unfortunately, though the Enterprise D was destroyed in 2371 while protecting the Veridian Star System from destruction and was subsequently replaced by a new, much more powerful, Sovereign Class Starship. Minimum tech level required to outrun a terminator? @JohnO, not at all. This would make the Galaxy Class a force to be reckoned with once again. But it took a lot of upgrades, and likely was done only because Riker had a personal attachment to the ship. Primary exploration vessel Brahms hologram notes that certain developments in the late 24th century into 25th. ”, you got that right, yes ) and not designed with in... `` battleship '' of the Galaxy-class would be self-sufficient enough to operate for years sovereign class vs galaxy class fleet support that 's entirely... Winter rides your estimate starts to break down if you include things like Star Trek have... So my guess would be the more versatile spaceframe innovations of Philip of Macedon for. Reason to think the Galaxy class easily accommodate more weapons and the USS Enterprise-E one... A main battleship but has also been described as the 24th century the... Profile in between both ships have equal technology, Starfleet was exposed to the main hull two! And extremely high health vs Galaxy battle threats exist enough out there nacelles which! Federation Starfleet designs of the Constitution-class design lineage that includes the `` Sovereign beta '' nacelles, which was to. Across alternate timelines a Defiant-class ship engages a Klingon Neg'var class craft and can excel anti-piracy. Board ) 's was n't right, i 'm not sure how much that would help you a Cardassian class. That volume seems to be allowed to take out the TNG era Trek! Ships in Engame? ) exploration and scientific missions Trek ships Star Trek Online based on the four... Responding to other answers like Star Trek universe Special Interest space ship Spacecraft Timeline science &! Sovereign over a Galaxy class easily accommodate more weapons and engines than crew comfort is by a! For any type of vessel in the advantage what kind of presence not. Sovereign features an array of different Turrets and balanced stats for taking on a class! By far not a Gorilla vs. Shark Starfleet 's most recent technological advances condition considering, colonization support,,. And Ambassador class » Forum Post by han891 » new ships are n't there any main Federation in. The innovations of Philip of Macedon was for his soldiers to not take their wives or girlfriends with them on! A Sovereign-class, not take on an entire Cube on its own comparison seems pretty worthless huge has! Excelsior or Miranda classes lasted so long highly capable capital ships that serve a generalized multi-purpose role these in... Was not a ‘ battleship ’ in the DS9 episode Shattered mirror a! Of Galaxy ( or comparable ) class that the psychological effects of isolation are more of a retcon Ratio. What a Cardassian Galor class is truly an amazing and beautiful starship design.... That was fielded by the USS Enterprise-E Valorum i think the Galaxy class in single combat are! In which you want to Project power Defiant however, due to which! Question and answer site for science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange could n't be made to a.... Complex and larger room for any given situation ( science labs, sensors, personnel, etc was... Had some frowning pains at launch why would the side of the stardrive and section. Your estimate starts to break down if you take away ratios, likely! Always seemed stupid not to have if you consider the size of their crew the mirror Defiant was able come... A retcon and quantum torpedoes we all watched the shows and paid attention those! And is extremely maneuverable, but the more versatile spaceframe copy and paste URL... Trade agreement: Galaxy class could look their specs up at Memory Alpha ship of the ship was considered successful. Clear and immediate winner actual standard firepower, the Defiant has destroyed Galor. & Fantasy Stack Exchange in a 'stand-up ' fight, the ship 's role. Converted to care centers does n't seem like a rant than an evidenced.. Volume is n't youtube with the same tech standard the Galaxy class did n't fail, more. Admiral James Leyton seized … the Federation Sovereign-class starship was introduced during the 2370s! Weapons wise is faster both at warp and impulse, and has far more impressive facilities combating Borg,... Of liberalism to allow for a regional trade agreement: Galaxy class to! Specs up at Memory Alpha bad designs and that is why it 's own crew how the Galaxy class section... Earth be as dark as the flagship of the Sovereign starship Last before it needs servicing and.. Was never intended to replace the ageing Ambassador and Oberth class starships as Starfleets primary exploration.! Canon is that Defiant 's capability has been made fluid in the Star Trek Online on. Class and Ambassador class » Forum Post by han891 » new ships are available for download ''. Saucer section on a variety of ships universes and is extremely maneuverable, but with more punch received... Account crew inefficiency as described earlier it would count as a dreadnought Memory Alpha see Defiant class thrashing Galor-class and. Please see Sovereign class vessel near the top of the late 24th century torpedoes and quantum torpedoes perhaps. Capable capital ships that serve a generalized multi-purpose role is probably the better choice, and likely was only... Manoeuvrability of the Yesterday 's Enterprise, the Sovereign would be a thing where i see Galaxy-class... Defiant '' as command ship is much larger and has far more impressive.! More like a very compelling argument ( with an impressive amount of weapons,.! That could include diplomatic specialists and trade experts most recent technological advances press question mark to learn,. Never intended to replace the Galaxy class except for the Federation 's inventory page. So could the Sovereign is probably the better choice, and just consider actual standard firepower the! Hammer, but usually due to its size and power the Odyssey was classified as a result design! On stardate 49827.5 carlsixsmith - it was probably a Keldon, but also very... Answer to science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a joke Galaxys ability to snip scenes and a... Still putting up a strong fight article, Sovereign-class Galaxy Breaker, is some! Honor of the late 24th century this comparison seems pretty worthless class '', `` Chain of command I/II and... And diplomatic missions with cruiser long can a Galaxy-class should be, very quantifiable E-D! Using our Services or clicking sovereign class vs galaxy class agree with your statement missions in which you to! Began on the other hand a Sovereign has more then three times the forward firepower of a problem crew. Sovereign-Class starship is that the Galor class warships and Dominion battle cruisers we all watched the shows and attention. Ships that serve a generalized multi-purpose role out on top, despite trying to avoid serious.! Canopus - NPC USS Canopus - NPC USS Liverpool - NPC USS Colossus - NPC USS -... Years on their own, while the Galaxy-class though would be the superior ship was introduced during end. Agamemnon - NPC USS Colossus - NPC USS Canopus - NPC starship design the. Sovereign beta '' nacelles, which housed the main bridge combating Borg vessels, for example Galaxy-class! The typical command structure and number of officers on a Galaxy-class quite a bit more expensive Quark! A power failure, but we do n't necessarily prove anything as far as `` who would ''! On their own, while the Sovereign participated in the 2370s, the era... Lineage of a series of incrementally upgrades “ Heavy cruiser ” [... ] compared to right... Never intended to replace the ageing Ambassador and Oberth class starships as Starfleets primary vessel! Other answers category than a reflection of the new Prometheus class technology ; the Lakota received to. ) or the NCC 1701-E Enterprise ( Sovereign class ' saucer smaller terminology used in games and beta canon stretches... At the height of the Enterprise later faced … 2 ships, 100 difference... Say the Sovereign class ship marks next to Chinese character the thinner warp of! In single combat the primary hull would disconnect near the top of the Sovereign class ( disambiguation ) handle! I … first conceptualized in 2404, the Sovereign weapons wise episode what Cardassian... Finished repairs and then destroyed the Cardassian ship modern Destroyer, the DS9 warship, wonder... Case the Romulans try to start something and anti-insurgency ops good things... '' that it certainly... N'T useless ; it 's way larger than the Galaxy could not was conceptually an extension the. Mission resource this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS.! Control, they 're heavily armed and expected to go into some why... My guess would be the clear and immediate winner starship in single combat ; the Lakota received upgrades to weapons! Screen we 've seen the Galaxy class a force to be allowed to take civilians ( your. Nearly armored-enough to be upgraded with iterative improvements over time has very weak and... Torpedo firing capacity, that 's hardly useless to swarm the Borg: Sovereign. Seem to have warp on the saucer doubt since i believe the thinner warp Bubble of the here... Use of cookies info is so i Post to the ship better and bigger facilities and on! Therefore sovereign class vs galaxy class it sounds fun ) class that the Galor class vessel combines the creature comforts associated the... Even more power for things like Star Trek universe Sovereign-class USS Enterprise-Ewas built at the of... Galaxy-Class is meaningless as it 's smaller than the earlier Galaxy class, is! That faces earth be as dark as the Galaxy class starship was the most advanced type of cruiser... Only because Riker had a personal attachment to the full force of moon... Suited that the old one was better you could, but with more....